| Content | 
Fully responds to all criteria of the assignmentClearly identifies and fully develops all ideas/themesProvides logical, valid and specific details and supportEffectively uses all relevant information, including outside sourcesDraws clear and appropriate conclusions | 
Sufficiently responds to most criteria of the assignmentIdentifies and develops main ideas/themes, but some may lack clarity or depthGenerally provides logical and valid details and supportEffectively uses most relevant information, including outside sourcesFor the most part, draws clear and appropriate conclusions | 
Does not respond or incompletely responds to some criteria of the assignmentDoes not identify or develop some main ideas/themesProvides support but may not be logical or valid; some details may be missingFrequently omits relevant information; outside sources may be inappropriate or missingDraws mostly unclear or inappropriate conclusions | 
Does not respond to most  criteria of the assignmentDoes not identify or develop most ideas/themesProvides few details and little  support or support that is illogical or invalidOmits relevant information; outside sources inappropriate or missingDraws unclear/inappropriate conclusions or omits conclusions entirely | 
| Organization | 
Clearly and consistently organizes ideasMaintains consistent focus and sense of purposeEffectively structures and orders paragraphsLinks ideas with smooth and effective transitions | 
Consistently organizes ideas, but structure may be formulaic or unsophisticatedGenerally maintains focusFor the most part, effectively structures and orders paragraphsFor the most part, effectively links ideas, but transitions may be unclear or ineffective | 
Frequently does not organizes ideas; structure is formulaic or unsophisticatedSometimes lacks focus or sense of purposeOften does not structure or order paragraphsLinks some ideas, but transitions are missing or unclear | 
Does not organize ideasConveys little or no focus or sense of purposeFor the most part, does not structure or order paragraphsDoes not link ideas | 
| Style  | 
Shows clear awareness of purpose and audienceUses sophisticated and varied sentence structureUses vocabulary and style that are appropriate to the audience | 
For the most part, shows awareness of purpose and audienceUses effective and varied sentence structureUses vocabulary and style that are mostly appropriate to the audience; some words may be used incorrectly | 
Is inconsistent in showing awareness of purpose and audienceUses little variety in sentence structure; some syntax errors may be presentUses vocabulary or style that are frequently inappropriate to the audience; words are often used incorrectly | 
Shows little awareness of purpose and audienceUses no variety in sentence structure; syntax errors frequently presentUses vocabulary or style that are inappropriate to the audience; words are consistently used incorrectly | 
| Mechanics | 
Makes virtually no grammar, punctuation, or spelling errorsUses correct citation format to document references and sources | 
Makes few grammar, punctuation, or spelling errors; these are not distracting to the readerIdentifies and documents most sources appropriately | 
Makes occasional grammar, punctuation, or spelling errors; these may be distracting to the readerSometimes uses correct citation format to document references and sources | 
Makes frequent grammar, punctuation, or spelling errors; these are distracting to the readerUses incorrect or no citation format to document references and sources |